Chappell: Windies need father figure

Given the tough opposition and their recent divisive problems, the West Indies will suffer for the lack of "a father figure" to lead them on their forthcoming tour of Australia, Ian Chappell, the former Australian captain, cautioned on Thursday.

"They really need someone like Clive Lloyd at this time, a father figure who can hold the team together and get the best out of them," Chappell said. Based on what he saw of the West Indies team on the tour of Sri Lanka in July and August, Chappell did not believe Shivnarine Chanderpaul, the West Indies captain, could provide that kind of leadership. "Chanderpaul was predictable and reactive in Sri Lanka," he said. "The only time you felt there would be a wicket was if there was a good ball or the pitch did something, not from anything creative from the captain."

Chappell noted the difference when Sylvester Joseph took over in Chanderpaul's absence in the one-day series. "Things started to happen because Joseph was proactive," he said. "The players aren't stupid. They know when the captain has ideas and is confident enough to put them into practice. It's a pity he isn't a good enough batsman to be in the team because he was always looking to make something happen."

Chanderpaul, who was played 88 Tests, took over as captain when Brian Lara opted out of the team before the first Test of the home series against South Africa last April in solidarity with six players who were omitted because they held personal endorsement contracts with former sponsors Cable & Wireless, direct competitors of the new sponsors, Digicel.

He led a team of mainly replacement players when ten of the originally chosen 13 refused to tour Sri Lanka because of the ongoing row over tour contracts between the West Indies Cricket Board (WICB) and the West Indies Players Association (WIPA). The return of most of those players, Lara and Ramnaresh Sarwan, the reappointed vice-captain, among them, is a potential flashpoint that would test Chanderpaul's leadership qualities.

Chappell acknowledged that the reunification of the West Indies team after the split caused by Kerry Packer's World Series Cricket (WICB) almost 30 years ago was different to the present case in many respects. But he maintained that Lloyd's captaincy was a major factor in ensuring that there were no residual problems and that the team developed into one of the strongest the game has known.

"The West Indies at present don't have that kind of experience and class and they're coming up against an Australian team that has regained its confidence after the defeat in the Ashes series and haven't lost a series at home in ages," Chappell said. "They need strong leadership more than ever."